6 Best Ice Fishing Lures for Panfish, research-based buying guide

6 Best Ice Fishing Lures for Panfish

Written by: Robert A. Thorson on November 16, 2026

Fishing › Ice fishing › Panfish lures

Panfish under the ice are picky. Tiny tungsten jigs tipped with soft plastics catch most of them, while small spoons and swimming lures call in active schools. We compared 16 ice lures and plastics and kept six that cover bluegill, crappie and perch.

Research guide · Updated November 2026 · How we research

This guide is based on research: maker specs, ratings and product listings. Where we test products ourselves, we add our results and label them clearly. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Lures compared16
Shortlisted6
Brands5
Smallest jigSize 10 tungsten

Our picks

Clam Drop-Kick Tungsten

Best overall

Clam Genz Drop-Kick Tungsten Jig, Size 10

A tiny tungsten jig with a flat top that shows up well on sonar. The bluegill specialist’s go-to head.

91 /100

LUCKYFISHING Tungsten Kit

Best value kit

LUCKYFISHING Glow Tungsten Ice Jigs, 1/16 oz

A kit of glow-in-the-dark tungsten jigs for less per jig than name brands.

86 /100

Maki Water Spider

Best soft plastic

Clam Maki Water Spider Plastic, Glow

An ultra-soft micro plastic with legs that move at the slightest jiggle. Tip any small jig with it.

84 /100

Northland Buck-Shot 1/8

Best for active schools

Northland UV Buck-Shot Rattle Spoon, 1/8 oz

A small spoon with a brass rattle chamber to call in perch and crappie from a distance.

84 /100

CJ&S Pulse-R

Best for crappie

Custom Jigs & Spins Pulse-R 2.4, 8 Pack

A slender plastic with a thin tail that quivers on the pause. A crappie favourite.

81 /100

Rapala Jigging Rap 07

Best for big crappie and perch

Rapala Jigging Rap, Size 07

A balanced swimming jig that darts in circles. Catches the biggest perch and crappie in a school.

81 /100

Compare every pick

Filter
TungstenGlowRattleKitTip it
Clam Drop-Kick TungstenClam Drop-Kick Tungsten91Tungsten jigSize 10Bluegill, crappie$
LUCKYFISHING Tungsten KitLUCKYFISHING Tungsten Kit86Tungsten jig kit1/16 ozCrappie, perch, gills$$
Maki Water SpiderMaki Water Spider84Micro plasticMicro, 8 packBluegill, crappie$
Northland Buck-Shot 1/8Northland Buck-Shot 1/884Rattle spoon1/8 ozPerch, crappie$$
CJ&S Pulse-RCJ&S Pulse-R81Micro plastic2.4 in, 8 packCrappie, perch$
Rapala Jigging Rap 07Rapala Jigging Rap 0781Swimming jig2¾ inJumbo perch, big crappie$

Research score = Panfish appeal 30% + Right size 20% + Gets down / shows on sonar 15% + Durability 15% + Value 20%. Each part is rated 0–100 from published specs and maker claims against what matters for panfish through the ice. It compares the picks in this guide; it is not a lab test. Filled dot = feature listed by the maker.

Best overall

1. Clam Genz Drop-Kick Tungsten Jig, Size 10

Clam Drop-Kick Tungsten

Tungsten is denser than lead, so a small jig sinks fast and you feel it better on light line. Clam says the Drop-Kick is about 30% heavier than lead for its size, and the flat top helps it show on sonar.

Tip it with a Maki or Pulse-R plastic or a spike, drop it to the fish on your flasher and jiggle it gently.

What stands out

  • Fast drop, great feel
  • Shows on sonar
  • Proven pattern

Watch out for

  • Costs more than lead
  • Single jig per pack
  • Only primary image
Research score91 /100
Panfish appeal95
Right size95
Gets down / shows on sonar95
Durability85
Value80
Material
Tungsten
Size
10
Shape
Drop-Kick, flat top
Colour
Black/white

Check price on Amazon

Best value kit

2. LUCKYFISHING Glow Tungsten Ice Jigs, 1/16 oz

LUCKYFISHING Tungsten Kit

If you want a box of tungsten without paying name-brand prices, this kit is a good start. The seller lists compact 1/16 oz tungsten heads with a glow-in-the-dark finish, which helps in deep or stained water and at dusk.

At 1/16 oz they are a little heavy for shallow bluegill but ideal for crappie and perch in deeper water.

What stands out

  • Many tungsten jigs for the money
  • Glow finish
  • Good for deeper fish

Watch out for

  • Heavier than ideal for shallow gills
  • Generic brand
  • Hook quality varies
Research score86 /100
Panfish appeal85
Right size80
Gets down / shows on sonar90
Durability80
Value95
Material
Tungsten
Weight
1/16 oz (1.85 g)
Finish
Glow
Pack
Multi-jig kit

Check price on Amazon

Best soft plastic

3. Clam Maki Water Spider Plastic, Glow

Maki Water Spider

Maki plastics are made to replace live bait on panfish jigs. The Water Spider’s soft legs pulse when you barely move the rod, which is what neutral fish want. Clam describes it as a small bait that fishes large.

They are durable for their size, so you can catch several fish before re-rigging.

What stands out

  • Moves with tiny jiggles
  • Durable
  • No live bait needed

Watch out for

  • Need jigs separately
  • Only primary image
  • Easy to lose in cold fingers
Research score84 /100
Panfish appeal95
Right size90
Gets down / shows on sonar50
Durability90
Value80
Count
8
Colour
Glow
Style
Water spider
Use
Tip a tungsten jig

Check price on Amazon

Best for active schools

4. Northland UV Buck-Shot Rattle Spoon, 1/8 oz

Northland Buck-Shot 1/8

When panfish are roaming, a spoon finds them faster than a tiny jig. The Buck-Shot is molded metal with a noisy brass rattle, and the UV finishes stand out in low light.

Many anglers remove the treble and tip a dropper with a spike or plastic. Switch to a tungsten jig when fish slow down.

What stands out

  • Calls fish in
  • Drops fast
  • Strong UV colours

Watch out for

  • Too aggressive for neutral fish
  • Treble tangles
  • Larger profile for small gills
Research score84 /100
Panfish appeal85
Right size75
Gets down / shows on sonar95
Durability90
Value80
Weight
1/8 oz
Rattle
Brass Buck-Shot chamber
Finish
UV, assorted
Hook
Treble

Check price on Amazon

Best for crappie

5. Custom Jigs & Spins Pulse-R 2.4, 8 Pack

CJ&S Pulse-R

Custom Jigs & Spins is one of the original panfish ice tackle makers, and the Pulse-R is a classic crappie plastic. The thin tail keeps moving after you stop the jig, which triggers suspended crappie.

Rig it on a horizontal or slightly larger tungsten jig for crappie and perch.

What stands out

  • Excellent crappie action
  • Durable
  • Bright colours

Watch out for

  • A little long for small bluegill
  • Main image only
  • Need jigs separately
Research score81 /100
Panfish appeal90
Right size85
Gets down / shows on sonar50
Durability85
Value85
Length
2.4 in
Count
8
Colour
Chartreuse/orange core
Use
Tip a jig

Check price on Amazon

Best for big crappie and perch

6. Rapala Jigging Rap, Size 07

Rapala Jigging Rap 07

The Jigging Rap swims out in a circle and back when you lift and drop it, imitating a fleeing minnow. It is best known for walleye, but the size 07 is a great big-perch and slab-crappie lure.

Use it to fire up a school, then switch to smaller jigs for the followers.

What stands out

  • Triggers the biggest fish
  • Covers water
  • Durable

Watch out for

  • Too big for bluegill
  • Many hooks to tangle
  • Needs a heavier rod
Research score81 /100
Panfish appeal80
Right size65
Gets down / shows on sonar90
Durability90
Value85
Length
2¾ in
Size
07
Action
Circular swim
Hooks
Front, rear and belly treble

Check price on Amazon

Which panfish ice lure is right for you?

Target
How are they biting?
Our match

Clam Genz Drop-Kick Tungsten Jig, Size 10

See details ↓

How to choose ice lures for panfish

Tungsten for speed and feel

Tungsten jigs drop faster and transmit more feel than lead of the same size.

Plastics replace bait

Micro plastics with legs or thin tails move with tiny jiggles and stay on the hook.

Spoons to find fish

Use a rattle spoon to call in a school, then downsize to catch more.

Light line

2–3 lb line helps tiny jigs fall and move naturally.

Use electronics

A flasher shows your jig and the fish; react to how they approach.

How we research

We gather every candidate from our earlier guide and current listings, compare maker specs, and score each lure against what matters for panfish through the ice. Anything out of stock or without clear specs is dropped.

  1. Find candidates16 ice jigs, plastics and spoons.
  2. Compare specsWeight, material, size and finish from the maker.
  3. ScorePanfish appeal 30%, size 20%, drop and sonar 15%, durability 15%, value 20%.
  4. Check stockRe-checked on every update.

Questions

What is the best ice jig for bluegill?

A small tungsten jig tipped with a micro plastic.

Tungsten or lead?

Tungsten for depth, speed and feel; lead is cheaper for shallow water.

What colour for panfish ice jigs?

Glow, pink, chartreuse and natural colours; switch until they bite.

What line for panfish ice fishing?

2–3 lb mono or fluorocarbon.

Do I need live bait?

Plastics work very well; spikes or waxies help on slow days.

Update log

Rebuilt: 6 panfish ice lures from 16 compared, research scores, sortable comparison and lure finder.

Leave a Comment