6 Best Paints for Soft Plastic Fishing Lures, research-based buying guide

6 Best Paints for Soft Plastic Fishing Lures

Written by: outgeekeditor on November 16, 2026

Fishing › Lure making › Soft plastic colour

Regular paint cracks and peels off soft plastic. To colour soft baits you either dip finished baits in a plastic dye or mix colorant into liquid plastisol before pouring. We compared 14 dyes, markers and colorants and kept six for both jobs.

Research guide · Updated November 2026 · How we research

This guide is based on research: maker specs, ratings and product listings. Where we test products ourselves, we add our results and label them clearly. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Products compared14
Shortlisted6
Dip dyes and markers3
Pouring colorants3

Our picks

Spike-It Dip-N-Glo 4 oz

Best dip dye

Spike-It Dip-N-Glo Soft Bait Dye, Chartreuse, 4 oz

The classic way to dip worm tails chartreuse. Adds colour and a scent-boosting attractant in seconds.

93 /100

Spike-It Garlic 5-Pack

Best colour pack

Spike-It Dip-N-Glo Garlic Lure Dye, 5 × 2 oz

Five garlic-scented dip colours in small bottles, so you can match the water and the day.

92 /100

Spike-It Markers

Best for details

Spike-It Scent Markers, Gamefish

Markers that colour and scent soft plastics for stripes, dots and claw tips.

87 /100

Eupheng Bright 6

Best bright colours

Eupheng 6-Colour Plastisol Colorant Set, Bright

Chartreuse, fluorescent orange, pink and other bright colours for stained water and reaction baits.

86 /100

BAITNEST 18 Colours

Best pouring colorant set

BAITNEST 18-Colour Plastisol Colorant Set

Eighteen highly pigmented colours for mixing into liquid plastisol when pouring your own baits.

85 /100

Eupheng Natural 6

Best natural colours

Eupheng 6-Colour Plastisol Colorant Set, Natural Tones

Six natural colours like watermelon, green pumpkin and motor oil for realistic baits.

84 /100

Compare every pick

Filter
ScentedFast dryMulti-colourPourFinished baits
Spike-It Dip-N-Glo 4 ozSpike-It Dip-N-Glo 4 oz93Dip dye4 ozFinished soft baits$$
Spike-It Garlic 5-PackSpike-It Garlic 5-Pack92Dip dye set5 × 2 ozFinished soft baits$$$
Spike-It MarkersSpike-It Markers87Scent markersSetDetails on finished baits$$
Eupheng Bright 6Eupheng Bright 686Plastisol colorant6 coloursPouring soft plastics$
BAITNEST 18 ColoursBAITNEST 18 Colours85Plastisol colorant18 × 10 mLPouring soft plastics$$
Eupheng Natural 6Eupheng Natural 684Plastisol colorant6 coloursPouring soft plastics$

Research score = Colour strength 30% + Stays on 25% + Ease of use 20% + Scent 10% + Value 15%. Each part is rated 0–100 from published specs and maker claims against what matters for colouring soft plastic baits. It compares the picks in this guide; it is not a lab test. Filled dot = feature listed by the maker.

Best dip dye

1. Spike-It Dip-N-Glo Soft Bait Dye, Chartreuse, 4 oz

Spike-It Dip-N-Glo 4 oz

Dipping tails in chartreuse is one of the oldest bass tricks, and Spike-It’s Dip-N-Glo is the standard product for it. It colours soft plastic directly, rather than sitting on top like paint, and adds a scent-boosting attractant.

Dip, wait a few seconds, wipe off the excess and store baits separately while they set.

What stands out

  • Colour soaks in and lasts
  • Very easy
  • Adds scent

Watch out for

  • Can stain fingers and boats
  • Strong smell
  • Only primary image
Research score93 /100
Colour strength95
Stays on90
Ease of use100
Scent90
Value85
Size
4 oz
Colour
Chartreuse
Type
Dip dye with scent
Made in
USA

Check price on Amazon

Best colour pack

2. Spike-It Dip-N-Glo Garlic Lure Dye, 5 × 2 oz

Spike-It Garlic 5-Pack

A small set of colours covers most needs: chartreuse for stained water, red for crawfish patterns and others for contrast. This pack has five 2 oz bottles in garlic scent, and the seller notes a two-second dip application.

Keep the lids tight; the dye evaporates if left open.

What stands out

  • Several colours
  • Garlic scent
  • Fast to apply

Watch out for

  • Higher price
  • Can stain
  • Bottle colours vary by pack
Research score92 /100
Colour strength95
Stays on90
Ease of use95
Scent95
Value80
Count
5 bottles
Size
2 oz each
Scent
Garlic
Application
Quick dip

Check price on Amazon

Best for details

3. Spike-It Scent Markers, Gamefish

Spike-It Markers

Markers let you add accents that dips cannot: stripes on a craw, dots on a creature bait or a coloured tail tip. Spike-It markers are made for soft plastics and add scent too.

They are ideal for quick changes on the water.

What stands out

  • Precise details
  • Quick on the water
  • Adds scent

Watch out for

  • Less coverage than dipping
  • Tips wear
  • Only one gallery image
Research score87 /100
Colour strength85
Stays on80
Ease of use100
Scent85
Value85
Type
Scent markers
Set
Gamefish colours
Use
Soft plastics
Brand
Spike-It

Check price on Amazon

Best bright colours

4. Eupheng 6-Colour Plastisol Colorant Set, Bright

Eupheng Bright 6

Bright colours trigger reaction strikes in stained water. This set includes chartreuse, fluorescent orange, fluorescent pink and red, which Eupheng lists for aggressive fish like pike, catfish and bass.

Use small amounts for laminate tails and accents.

What stands out

  • Strong bright colours
  • Cheap
  • Good for accents

Watch out for

  • Pouring only
  • Easy to overdo
  • No scent
Research score86 /100
Colour strength95
Stays on100
Ease of use75
Scent30
Value95
Colours
6 bright
Includes
Chartreuse, fluorescent orange and pink, red
Type
Plastisol colorant
Use
Pouring

Check price on Amazon

Best pouring colorant set

5. BAITNEST 18-Colour Plastisol Colorant Set

BAITNEST 18 Colours

If you pour your own soft plastics, colour goes into the liquid plastisol before it sets, so it can never rub off. BAITNEST’s set has 18 colours in 10 mL bottles and is highly pigmented, so a few drops go a long way.

Use with good ventilation and follow plastisol safety instructions.

What stands out

  • Colour never wears off
  • Many colours
  • Small dose needed

Watch out for

  • Only for pouring
  • Need plastisol and molds
  • No scent
Research score85 /100
Colour strength95
Stays on100
Ease of use75
Scent30
Value90
Colours
18
Size
10 mL each
Type
Plastisol colorant
Use
Pouring baits

Check price on Amazon

Best natural colours

6. Eupheng 6-Colour Plastisol Colorant Set, Natural Tones

Eupheng Natural 6

Most bass baits are natural colours, and this Eupheng set covers the classics: watermelon green, pumpkin green, motor oil and more. It is a cheap start for home pouring.

Combine with glitter for classic patterns.

What stands out

  • Classic bass colours
  • Cheap
  • Easy to blend

Watch out for

  • Pouring only
  • Fewer colours
  • No scent
Research score84 /100
Colour strength90
Stays on100
Ease of use75
Scent30
Value95
Colours
6 natural
Includes
Watermelon, pumpkin green, motor oil
Type
Plastisol colorant
Use
Pouring

Check price on Amazon

Which product is right for you?

What are you doing?
Colour style
Our match

Spike-It Dip-N-Glo Soft Bait Dye, Chartreuse, 4 oz

See details ↓

How to colour soft plastic lures

Do not use normal paint

Acrylic and enamel paints crack and peel off soft plastic.

Dip dyes for finished baits

Plastic dyes soak into the surface and last; dip tails or claws.

Colorant for pouring

Mix plastisol colorant into liquid plastic before pouring.

Ventilate

Work outside or with good airflow, wear gloves and keep dyes away from kids.

Let them set

Give dipped baits time to dry before bagging.

How we research

We gather every candidate from our earlier guide and current listings, compare maker specs, and score each product against what matters for colouring soft plastics. Anything out of stock or without clear specs is dropped.

  1. Find candidates14 dyes, markers and colorants.
  2. Compare specsType, size, colours and scent from the maker.
  3. ScoreColour 30%, stays on 25%, ease 20%, scent 10%, value 15%.
  4. Check stockRe-checked on every update.

Questions

Can I paint soft plastic lures?

Use plastic dyes or markers; regular paint peels off.

How do I dip worm tails chartreuse?

Dip the tail in Dip-N-Glo for a few seconds and wipe off the excess.

Does dye wash off in the water?

Good dyes soak in and last many casts.

How do I colour plastisol?

Add a few drops of colorant to the liquid plastic before pouring.

Is lure dye safe?

Use gloves and ventilation; follow the label.

Update log

Rebuilt: 6 dyes, markers and colorants from 14 compared, research scores, comparison and finder.

Leave a Comment