10 Best Soft Plastic Baits for Crappie, research-based buying guide

10 Best Soft Plastic Baits for Crappie

Written by: Robert A. Thorson on November 16, 2026

Fishing › Crappie › Soft plastics

Crappie plastics are small, 1.5 to 2.5 in, and color matters by water clarity. We compared 36 crappie baits and kits and kept ten.

Research guide · Updated November 2026 · How we research

This guide is based on research: maker specs, ratings and product listings. Where we test products ourselves, we add our results and label them clearly. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Products compared36
Shortlisted10
Brands9
Sizes1–2.75 in

Our picks

Crappie Magnet 115pc

Best big kit

Crappie Magnet Best of Best Kit, 115 Pc

A 115-piece kit with split-tail bodies and Double Cross jigheads.

92 /100

Bobby Garland 52 pc Kit

Best starter kit

Bobby Garland 52 pc Crappie Kit

A complete kit with Baby Shads, Itty Bit Slab Hunt’Rs and more.

91 /100

Crappie Magnet 78pc

Best for vertical jigging

Crappie Magnet 78pc Kit

Split-tail bodies with jigheads in a storage kit.

91 /100

XFISHMAN Tube Kit

Best tube kit

XFISHMAN Crappie Tube Jig Kit, 120 pcs, 12 Colors

120 tubes and jigheads in 12 colors.

91 /100

XFISHMAN 135 Kit

Best value kit

XFISHMAN Crappie Jigs and Lures Kit, 135 and 40 Piece

Soft plastics, jigheads and split-tails in a 135-piece kit.

91 /100

Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50

Best overall

Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50-Count Bulk Pack, 2″

The top-selling crappie plastic in a 50-count wet pack.

90 /100

VMSIXVM Tube Kit

Best pre-rigged tubes

VMSIXVM Crappie Tube and Jig Head Kit, 124 pcs

Tube baits, jigheads and worms in one kit.

89 /100

Houderrong Curly Grubs

Best curly tail

Houderrong Curly Tail Grub Kit, 1–5 in

A curly tail grub kit with a stabilizer fin.

88 /100

Lanmoon 100pcs

Cheapest pick

Lanmoon 100pcs Crappie Lures Kit

100 soft plastic crappie baits in a box.

88 /100

Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow

Best scented

Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow, 1 in

A tiny scented minnow soaked in attractant.

82 /100

Compare every pick

Filter
JigheadsScentedBoxMulti-colorBulk
Crappie Magnet 115pcCrappie Magnet 115pc92Split tail115Stocking up$$$
Bobby Garland 52 pc KitBobby Garland 52 pc Kit91Mixed kit52New crappie anglers$$
Crappie Magnet 78pcCrappie Magnet 78pc91Split tail78Vertical jigging brush$$
XFISHMAN Tube KitXFISHMAN Tube Kit91Tube120Color experimenting$$$
XFISHMAN 135 KitXFISHMAN 135 Kit91Mixed kit135Families and beginners$$
Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50Bobby Garland Baby Shad 5090Spear-tail shad50Jigging and shooting docks$$
VMSIXVM Tube KitVMSIXVM Tube Kit89Tube kit124All-round crappie kit$$$$
Houderrong Curly GrubsHouderrong Curly Grubs88Curly tail grub90+ (2 in)Swimming retrieves$$$
Lanmoon 100pcsLanmoon 100pcs88Mixed plastics100Budget restock$
Berkley Gulp! Alive! MinnowBerkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow82Scented minnowSee listingTough, cold-water bites$

Research score = Action 25% + Crappie size 20% + Durability 20% + Colors & variety 15% + Value 20%. Each part is rated 0–100 from published specs and maker claims against what matters for crappie fishing with jigs. It compares the picks in this guide; it is not a lab test. Filled dot = feature listed by the maker.

Best big kit

1. Crappie Magnet Best of Best Kit, 115 Pc

Crappie Magnet 115pc

The Best of Best kit includes Crappie Magnet bodies and Double Cross jigheads.

More colors for changing conditions.

What stands out

  • Lots of colors
  • Proven
  • Complete

Watch out for

  • Pricier
  • Split tail only
  • Box fills fast
Research score92 /100
Action90
Crappie size100
Durability85
Colors & variety95
Value90
Count
115
Style
Split tail
Heads
Double Cross
Use
Crappie, panfish

Check price on Amazon

Best starter kit

2. Bobby Garland 52 pc Crappie Kit

Bobby Garland 52 pc Kit

Bobby Garland’s kit includes 24 Baby Shads plus Itty Bit Slab Hunt’Rs and other baits.

It takes the guesswork out of color and style.

What stands out

  • Proven baits
  • Variety
  • Good value

Watch out for

  • Few of each
  • Box basic
  • Check jighead count
Research score91 /100
Action95
Crappie size95
Durability85
Colors & variety90
Value90
Count
52
Includes
24 Baby Shad, Slab Hunt’R and more
Brand
Bobby Garland
Use
Crappie

Check price on Amazon

Best for vertical jigging

3. Crappie Magnet 78pc Kit

Crappie Magnet 78pc

Crappie Magnet’s split tail stays open with little action, perfect for vertical jigging.

The kit includes bodies and jigheads.

What stands out

  • Proven pattern
  • Complete kit
  • Cheap

Watch out for

  • Little swimming action
  • Small heads
  • Bodies tear
Research score91 /100
Action90
Crappie size100
Durability85
Colors & variety85
Value95
Count
78
Style
Split tail
Includes
Bodies, jigheads
Use
Vertical jigging

Check price on Amazon

Best tube kit

4. XFISHMAN Crappie Tube Jig Kit, 120 pcs, 12 Colors

XFISHMAN Tube Kit

A tube’s hollow body and tentacles pulse on the fall, a classic crappie bait.

XFISHMAN’s kit covers 12 colors.

What stands out

  • Many colors
  • Complete
  • Good value

Watch out for

  • Generic plastic
  • Small heads only
  • Box basic
Research score91 /100
Action85
Crappie size95
Durability85
Colors & variety95
Value95
Count
120
Colors
12
Style
Tube
Includes
Jigheads

Check price on Amazon

Best value kit

5. XFISHMAN Crappie Jigs and Lures Kit, 135 and 40 Piece

XFISHMAN 135 Kit

XFISHMAN’s kit has soft plastics, jigheads and split-tail baits in many colors.

Everything needed to start.

What stands out

  • Cheap
  • Huge variety
  • Complete

Watch out for

  • Generic quality
  • Box crowded
  • Heads small
Research score91 /100
Action85
Crappie size95
Durability80
Colors & variety95
Value100
Count
135 (also 40)
Includes
Plastics, jigheads
Colors
Many
Use
Crappie, panfish

Check price on Amazon

Best overall

6. Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50-Count Bulk Pack, 2″

Bobby Garland Baby Shad 50

Bobby Garland’s Baby Shad is the best-selling crappie soft plastic, now in a 50-count bulk bag.

The solid body and thin spear tail quiver on the fall.

What stands out

  • Proven
  • Lots of baits
  • Easy access pack

Watch out for

  • One color per pack
  • Jigheads extra
  • Can tear
Research score90 /100
Action95
Crappie size100
Durability85
Colors & variety70
Value95
Length
2 in
Count
50
Pack
Wet, flip lid
Style
Spear tail

Check price on Amazon

Best pre-rigged tubes

7. VMSIXVM Crappie Tube and Jig Head Kit, 124 pcs

VMSIXVM Tube Kit

VMSIXVM’s kit pairs durable tubes with jigheads.

The material resists bites so baits last longer.

What stands out

  • Durable
  • Variety
  • Complete

Watch out for

  • Pricier
  • Generic
  • Heavy box
Research score89 /100
Action85
Crappie size95
Durability85
Colors & variety90
Value90
Count
124
Includes
Tubes, jigheads, worms
Material
Bite resistant
Use
Crappie

Check price on Amazon

Best curly tail

8. Houderrong Curly Tail Grub Kit, 1–5 in

Houderrong Curly Grubs

Houderrong’s grubs have a balanced stabilizer fin and flame curly tail for steady action.

Multiple sizes from 1 to 5 in.

What stands out

  • Constant action
  • Sizes for all panfish
  • Bulk

Watch out for

  • Bigger sizes for bass
  • Jigheads extra
  • Newer brand
Research score88 /100
Action95
Crappie size85
Durability85
Colors & variety90
Value85
Sizes
1–5 in
2 in count
90
Colors
6
Feature
Stabilizer fin

Check price on Amazon

Cheapest pick

9. Lanmoon 100pcs Crappie Lures Kit

Lanmoon 100pcs

Lanmoon packs 100 soft baits in a box for crappie, trout and panfish.

A cheap way to stock up.

What stands out

  • Very cheap
  • Many baits
  • Box

Watch out for

  • Softer plastic
  • No jigheads
  • Generic colors
Research score88 /100
Action80
Crappie size95
Durability75
Colors & variety90
Value100
Count
100
Box
Included
Use
Crappie, trout, panfish
Brand
Lanmoon

Check price on Amazon

Best scented

10. Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow, 1 in

Berkley Gulp! Alive! Minnow

Gulp! Alive! baits are soaked in a powerful attractant with extreme scent dispersion.

A 1 in minnow is perfect tipped on a jig.

What stands out

  • Scent sells
  • Great tipper
  • Lifelike

Watch out for

  • Messy liquid
  • Dries out if left open
  • Small
Research score82 /100
Action85
Crappie size90
Durability75
Colors & variety70
Value85
Length
1 in
Scent
Gulp! Alive!
Pack
Resealable tub (see listing)
Use
Tipping jigs

Check price on Amazon

Which crappie plastic fits you?

How do you fish?
What do you need?
Budget
Our match

Crappie Magnet Best of Best Kit, 115 Pc

See details ↓

How to choose crappie soft plastics

Size

1.5–2.5 in matches crappie forage.

Style

Shads quiver, tubes pulse, curly tails swim.

Colors

Natural in clear water, chartreuse and dark in stained.

Jighead weight

1/32–1/16 oz for most depths.

Tip with scent

A small scented bait helps in cold water.

How we research

We gather every candidate from our earlier guide and current listings, compare maker specs, and score each bait for crappie. Anything out of stock or without clear specs is dropped.

  1. Find candidates36 crappie plastics and kits.
  2. Compare specsSize, style, count and colors.
  3. ScoreAction 25%, size 20%, durability 20%, variety 15%, value 20%.
  4. Check stockRe-checked on every update.

Questions

What’s the best crappie plastic?

A 2 in shad-style bait like the Baby Shad.

What jighead weight for crappie?

1/32 to 1/16 oz.

What color for crappie?

Match water clarity.

Tubes or shads?

Both work; tubes pulse, shads quiver.

Do I need scent?

It can help on slow days.

Update log

Rebuilt: 10 crappie soft plastic picks from 36 compared, research scores, sortable comparison and finder.

Leave a Comment